Mullet Review TrackerUnofficial fan tracker

Day 17Posted Jun 17, 2026

Asian Buffet

Columbus, OH
5666 W Broad St, Galloway, OH 43119

An aquarium-like buffet with great smiley potatoes and pigs in a blanket, but a ghost-white pizza, messed-up goons, tasteless mac and yesterday's-food vibes. Knocked down to three.

Closed crab rangoon: rated 3.0 or higher3.0His ratingYelp said 3.3
  • Rangoons Not gooning
  • Pizza YesWhite as a ghost, but it tastes okay. 'Work on that pizza, man.'
  • Desserts Pineapple marshmallow salad, Oreo, Fortune cookie
  • Price $11.83/person ($23.65 for 2)

Dishes

  • Smiley potatoesSo great: 'this is above average. This is quality.'01:57
  • Pigs in a blanketThese are so good.01:50
  • Italian turkeyA turkey he'd never had Italian. It's just Italian dressing and turkey.01:39
  • Crab rangoonIt tastes wrong: 'What is with these guys messing these up?' (see Rangoons).02:04
  • SushiA stale cracker-like roll with big cream cheese, like they put peanut butter chicken in the sushi.02:14
  • Mac and cheeseDoesn't taste like anything at all.02:43

What he said

“I'll knock it down to three stars. I don't think anything I had was absolutely terrible, but a lot of it was weird.”
04:41 from TikTok's auto-captions
“Why does it taste like that? I'm not gooning. What? What is with these guys messing these up?”
03:20 from TikTok's auto-captions
“Kind of like being in the Newport Aquarium or something.”
00:28 from TikTok's auto-captions
“I don't care what your wife says, this is above average. This is quality.”
03:00 from TikTok's auto-captions
“This is white as a ghost. Like, I mean, it tastes okay.”
01:29 from TikTok's auto-captions
“So I feel like a lot of that stuff was cold, and it's a little lazy to throw ice cubes on the lettuce.”
04:33 from TikTok's auto-captions

What he didn't love

  • Freshness: A lot of it was cold and weird, like yesterday's food, even right after opening. 04:33
  • Salad bar: Ice cubes thrown on the lettuce: 'a little lazy'. 00:45

Also noticed

  • A bridge over the pond, like being in the Newport Aquarium. 00:24
  • Ice on the lettuce, the first time he's had that. 00:45

More